Secrets of the Watch House: Book Review

Secrets of the Watch House by Jenny Ashcroft is a gothic-tinged historical mystery full of secrets and suspicion

Synopsis: Secrets of the Watch House

In this atmospheric and suspense-laced historical novel, Jenny Ashcroft transports readers to 1930s Cornwall—a windswept landscape steeped in mystery and isolation. Violet Ellis, seeking a fresh start after her father’s disgrace, accepts a position on the eerie and remote Aoife’s Bay. But what she finds there is anything but a haven.

Her employer, James Atherton, is a wealthy widower shrouded in scandal after the suspicious death of his wife, Elizabeth. As Violet begins to fall for him, anonymous letters begin to spread through the bay, dredging up secrets the locals would rather keep buried—and putting Violet in the crosshairs of gossip and danger. As the walls of the watch house seem to whisper their own stories, Violet must determine who she can trust before history repeats itself.

Secrets of the Watch House is a gripping novel where love, betrayal, and long-buried truths collide in the shadow of a woman’s mysterious death.

Review: Secrets of the Watch House

Set on a windswept island off the coast of England, Jenny Ashcroft’s Secrets of the Watch House blends historical fiction with psychological suspense in a dual-timeline story of love, grief, and buried truths.

The novel centers on Violet Ellis, a young woman trying to escape the shadow of her father’s criminal past. When she meets James, a man still grieving the mysterious death of his wife Elizabeth, Violet believes she has found a new beginning. But when she follows James to the remote island he calls home, strange letters begin to surface—letters that cast doubt on what really happened to Elizabeth the night she disappeared.

Told across two timelines—1934, when Violet arrives on the island, and the earlier years of James and Elizabeth’s relationship—Secrets of the Watch House slowly peels back the layers of its mystery. Ashcroft does a commendable job of guiding the reader through the shifting narratives without confusion, a crucial feat for a dual-timeline thriller. The atmosphere is thick with tension, heightened by the isolated setting and a growing sense that something—or someone—is watching.

While technically a historical mystery, the novel leans heavily into gothic elements. The rugged island landscape, the looming watch house itself, and the suggestion of supernatural interference all contribute to a haunting tone that lingers throughout.

That said, the novel isn’t without its flaws. At 480 pages, the pacing does drag in places, particularly in the middle. A tighter edit could have enhanced the suspense without sacrificing the emotional depth or rich detail that Ashcroft is known for.

Conclusion

Secrets of the Watch House may not be a fast-paced thriller, but it delivers a moody, character-driven mystery with just the right touch of the gothic. For readers who enjoy slow-burn suspense, layered timelines, and atmospheric settings, this novel is worth the journey.

• Facebook
• X
• Threads
• Pinterest
• Pocket

Like follow or share if you would want similar content.

Above all Keep Safe and treat people fairly.

Mark.